|
Abstract
|
The reasons for the relevance of the analyzed research are given in the review. The novelty of the work is in the position of the author of the study concerning the application of the liberal legal (Western European), Soviet, American concepts of procedural law in the Russian criminal
proceedings. The opinion of the author of the thesis concerning the information concept of criminal proceedings, as well as the concept of due process of law, is estimated. A number of judgments,
conclusions and proposals are supported by the opponent and recognized as being significant both from theoretical and practical points of view. conclusions and suggestions of the applicant have
passed obligatory approbation. At the same time, certain provisions of the developed concept require clarification. In particular, the applicant proposes two ways of the development of domestic criminal
procedure legislation: 1) the implementation of the provisions of international conventions, taking into account the legal mentality of the Russian society, 2) the rejection of the norms of international law
and relying solely on national legal identity. however, the preferred variant is not distinguished. Despite the comments, the reviewer states that the thesis has an internal unity, contains new scientific results
and provisions that testify to the personal contribution of the applicant to the science of criminal procedure.
|
